SSL Certificate website security Pay with Debit/Credit Card or PayPalAccount

All Our Lovies Are USED - Many Look NEW

Like Coupons? Register and Subscribe to our Newsletter

Can't find what you need? - Use our FREE Plush Memories Lost Toy Search Service

"Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above, and cometh down from the Father of lights..."
James 1:17 KJV

4,774 Lovies Listed as of 03/24/2017

Featured Plush

Site Testimonials

Add Testimonial

Thank you so much!

A little over a year ago, my daughter sent her green lovey or night-night as she calls it out of town with my husband so he could sleep with it. He left it at the hotel. We tried contacting the hotel on multiple occasions to see if they found it but could never get any response.

I searched the internet for a replacement because she was so sad about it. I was able to find a similar one by the same company but not exactly the same. We ordered that one and she was happy to have a green bunny again but she was still sad about the one that was lost.

A few nights ago, she saw a picture of that old night-night and started crying.

That's when I stumbled across your page and saw the same one that we lost listed! It came in yesterday and she is so happy!

Thank you so much!!

- April, 03/17/2017 7:45AM

Mom Loved It

Every Valentine's Day I buy my mom a valentine snoopy plush. I have bought just about every available one for retail sale that I have been able to get my hands on. I finally found one that I haven't seen before at Dirty Butter, and it was perfect. Thank you for the excellent service and pleasant transaction. P.S. my Mom absolutely loved it

- Zack M, 02/20/2017 4:13PM

Great service

The bunny I received looks brand new, was very reasonably priced and came super fast. Thank you for great service.

- Stephanie, 02/07/2017 11:27AM


Just a quick thank you. As silly as this sounds my daughter had the cutsiemoosie toy, and she gave it to her puppy years ago. It was his baby and best friend. The only toy he didn't destroy. It finally wore out, and I could never find another.

He got attacked by another dog, and I went on the search, because he was so sad and sore. You had it, and I sent it to them.

He is so happy! I think it is helping him heal.

- Mary, 01/17/2017 6:47PM
More ...